Re: What 'War' Was That Idiot Talking about?

Gary DeWaay wrote:
> In article <ObLhk.17111$jI5.4951@[EMAIL PROTECTED]
>, 
> sfgeorge@[EMAIL PROTECTED]
 George Grapman says... 
>  
> 
>> bvallely@[EMAIL PROTECTED]
 wrote:
>>>>    A quick google groups search for the last two months (something
that
>>>> Vallely claims takes hours)>
>>> .
>>> I said no such thing.
>>>
>>    Here is Vallely saying that the NY Times and Obama have both said we

>> won the war:
>>
>>
>>
http://groups.google.com/group/alt.politics/msg/beb83ea6818d8a2b?hl=en&dmode=source
>>
>> The problem is that even Obama and the New York Times admit that we
>> won the war.
>>
>>
>>    Here is Vallely answering a request to back up that claim by asking 
>> if I read papers and telling us they were "lead stories".
>>
>>
http://groups.google.com/group/alt.politics/msg/372f043889b1146b?hl=en&dmode=source
>>
>>
>>  >   You, of course, have quotes to back up those claims.
>> .
>> Don't you ever read a newspaper?  I mean, seriously, these were lead
>> stories.
>>
>>    And here is Vallely instead of posting a link saying that it takes 
>> him hours to find links to back up his claims. One would think if Obama

>> said we won the war that comment would be easy to find.
>>
>>
>>
http://groups.google.com/group/alt.politics/msg/f7dc059f47484498?hl=en&dmode=source
>>
>>  >    I read at least three print papers each day including the NY
Times
>>  > and several more on line. Since they were lead stories you should
have
>>  > no trouble posting them.
>> .
>> The problem I have is not posting the article, it's wasting time
>> looking up articles for you.
>>
>> You have a long history of simply ignoring posts after I've spent
>> hours looking them up, or pretending they say things they simply don't
>> say.
>>
>>
> 
> 
> Vallely needs to find a forum where they don't archive his posts.
> 
> He can then pretend he isn't a pathological liar, or a hypocrite more 
> easily.

   The pattern:

   Vallely makes a claim.
   He is asked to back up that claim.
   He says he never made the claim.
   His claim is reposted.
   He denies making the claim but includes the repost of his words in 
his reply.
   The words are reposted along with his denial.
   He accuses the poster of lying.


     If,as Vallely claims, one is lying when one reposts a Vallely 
message doesn't that mean that Vallely lied?