Talk About Network

Google


Register and Login
Nick
Password
Register create new account Sign up is FREE and you can post replies, new topics, bookmark posts and more!
Recover lost password


Government > Guns > Re: How the U.S...
Latest [ Topics | Posts ] Archive Post A New Topic Post a Reply
<< Topic < Post Post 1 of 5 Topic 51166 of 58493
Post > Topic >>

Re: How the U.S. Military Just Got Schooled by a 'Rag-Tag' Neighborhood Army in Iraq

by "_ Prof. Jonez _" <theprof@[EMAIL PROTECTED] > Apr 4, 2008 at 08:44 AM

bongblaster@[EMAIL PROTECTED]
 wrote:
> More proof American gun-slingers and their Jewish money-men can be
> defeated on the battlefield:
>
>
> How the U.S. Just Got Schooled by a 'Rag-Tag' Neighborhood Army in
> Iraq
> http://www.alternet.org/waroniraq/81147/
>
> A week ago, Bush called the offensive in Basra a "defining moment" for
> Iraq. Suddenly he's gotten very quiet.
>
> What happened in Iraq this week was a beautiful lesson in the weird
> laws of guerrilla warfare. Unfortunately, it was the Americans who got
> schooled. Even now, people at my office are saying, "We won, right?
> Sadr told his men to give up, right?"
>
> Wrong. Sadr won big. Iran won even bigger. Maliki, the Iraqi Army,
> Petraeus and Cheney lost.
>
> For people raised on stories of conventional war, where both sides
> fight all-out until one side loses and gives up, what happened in Iraq
> this past week makes no sense at all. Sadr's Mahdi Army humiliated the
> Iraq Army on all fronts. In Basra, the Army's grand offensive,
> code-named "The Charge of the Knights," got turned into "The Total
> Humiliation of the Knights," like something out of an old Monty Python
> skit.
>
> Thousands of police who were supposed to be backing up the Iraqi Army
> either refused to fight or defected to Sadr's Mahdi Army. In Basra,
> the Iraqi Army was stopped dead and clearly in danger of being crushed
> or forced to retreat from the city. In Baghdad, Sadr's militia was
> rocketing the Green Zone non-stop -- not a good look for the "Surge is
> working" PR drive -- and driving the Iraqi Army clean out of the
> 2.5-million-strong ****a slum, Sadr City. And in every poor ****a
> neighborhood in cities and towns all over Iraq, local units of the
> Mahdi Army were attacking the government forces.
>
> Then, after four days of uninterruptedly kicking Iraqi Army ass, Sadr
> graciously announces that he's telling his men to end their "armed
> appearances" on the streets. Makes no sense, right? It makes a ton of
> sense, but you have to stop thinking of formal battles like Gettysburg
> and Stalingrad and think long and slow, like a guerrilla.
>
> If you want to know how not to think about Iraq, just start with
> anything ever said or imagined by Cheney or Bush. Our Commander in
> Chief declared a week ago when the Iraqi Army first marched into
> Basra, "I would say this is a defining moment in the history of a free
> Iraq." When the Iraqi Army fled a few days later, he suddenly got very
> quiet. But anybody could see how deluded the poor ****er is just by
> all the nonsense he managed to cram into that 15-word sentence. I
> mean, "the history of a free Iraq"?
>
> But that's nothing compared to Bush's fundamentally wrong notion that
> there's even such a thing as a "defining moment" in an urban guerrilla
> war. Guerrilla wars are slow, crock-pot wars. To win this kind of war,
> the long war, takes patience. Trying to force a "defining moment" by
> military action is not just ignorant and idiotic, but risks further
> demoralizing your side when that moment doesn't happen, as it
> inevitably won't. What happens when you launch premature strikes on a
> neighborhood-based group like the Mahdi Army is that you just end up
> convincing their neighborhoods that the occupiers are the enemy, and
> the Mahdi boys -- local guys you've known all your life -- are heroes,
> defending your glorious slum from the foreigners and their lackeys.
>
> By the time a homegrown group like Sadr's is ready to "announce
> itself" on the streets, it's put in years of serious grassroots work
> winning over the locals block by block. The Mahdi Army runs its own
> little world in the neighborhoods it controls. It distributes food to
> the poor, deals out rough justice to the local criminals, and runs the
> checkpoints that keep Sunni suicide bombers off the block. It's the
> home team, the Oakland Raiders times one million, for people in places
> like Sadr City. You can't eradicate it without eradicating the whole
> neighborhood -- or making it so rich that people don't need a gang.
> That's probably the only sure way to end guerrilla wars: make the
> locals so rich they're not interested in gang life any more. And
> that's not going to happen any time soon for the people crammed into
> places like Sadr City. Until then, the Mahdi Army is their team and
> they're sticking by it.
>
> By attacking Sadr's neighborhoods this week, Maliki's troops pushed
> the ****a m***** closer to Sadr; and by losing, they made the slum
> people prouder than ever of their home team. That's what you get when
> you go for a "defining moment" in guerrilla war.
 




 5 Posts in Topic:
Re: How the U.S. Military Just Got Schooled by a 'Rag-Tag' Neigh
"_ Prof. Jonez _&quo  2008-04-04 08:44:49 
Re: How the U.S. Military Just Got Schooled by a 'Rag-Tag'
Benj <bjacoby@[EMAIL P  2008-04-04 09:28:29 
Re: How the U.S. Military Just Got Schooled by a 'Rag-Tag' Neigh
"Herb Martin" &  2008-04-04 12:33:30 
Re: How the U.S. Military Just Got Schooled by a 'Rag-Tag' Neigh
"Reality_Check©"  2008-04-04 21:16:15 
Re: How the U.S. Military Just Got Schooled by a 'Rag-Tag' Neigh
grey_ghost471-newsgroups@  2008-04-05 11:08:47 

Post A Reply:
  Go here to Signup

AddThis Feed Button


About - Advertising - Contact - Frequently Asked Questions - Privacy Policy - Terms of Use - Signup

Contact
tan12V112 Fri Dec 5 4:58:52 CST 2008.