Re: Second Amendment:"Iran has the right to develop Nuclear Weapons"

"Immortalist" <reanimater_2000@[EMAIL PROTECTED]
> wrote in message 
news:a9022b7e-3614-4ad0-bb6d-88dd57f7cf64@[EMAIL PROTECTED]
> On Jul 11, 10:31 am, "Topp@[EMAIL PROTECTED]
" <toppro...@[EMAIL PROTECTED]
> wrote:
>> "lorad" <lorad...@[EMAIL PROTECTED]
> wrote in message
>>
>>
news:442ab9c6-0a7d-45e7-b9a8-a8c9f32a1aa9@[EMAIL PROTECTED]
>> On Jul 11, 8:48 am, "Topp@[EMAIL PROTECTED]
" <toppro...@[EMAIL PROTECTED]
> wrote:
>>
>> >As far as I know they have adhered to the NP Treaty.
>> >What makes you think they have not?
>>
>> First, they sit on OIL.  they don't need Nuke Power.  they could just 
>> burn
>> their own oil for power.
>
> I don't want to sound like I am sup****ting Iran or anything but I am
> curious about where this "standard" of how much natural energy sources
> a nation needs before it must eliminate other energy sources from
> their rights to have and produce energy? This is in response to your
> position about what they "need" which carries a lot force in the
> apparent warrant of your conclusion.
>
> http://www.philosophypages.com/lg/e01.htm
>
>> Second, the # of  Enrichment plants they have/plan on building would 
>> create
>> more material than they would need for the reactors they want
>> third, their threats to the rest of the world...
>> fourth, the fact that they see pakistan Nuke capable..I think they want
>> their own.
>> fifth, the fact they do not want anypart of the International
communities
>> involvment...Something to hide????
>                                                                         
  
>                                                                         
  
>             ------  
>  >>None to you scribbled. This is exactly the problem.  How much Uranium
is 
> needed for a reactor is exactly known. And they want to make an excess
of 
> uranium for weapons and not have to have verification to anyone.  And
they 
> want to dictate terms that they can do so under. Once the excess is made

> and hidden . It would take an invasion to find it. The idea itself is a 
> violation of the NP treaty. They clearly stated their intentions of 
> violating the treaty. They clearly wont allow inspections. And wont
accept 
> the uranium for their powerplants in exchange for not making Enrichment 
> facilities. Their intent is quite clear . It doesn't matter if a
violation 
> was made or not.